Hurricane Katrina & The Poor

by pittcaleb Email    742 views

Link: http://abcnews.go.com/WNT/HurricaneKatrina/story?id=1081329&page=1

I am following hurricane coverage probably more than most and reading article after article at various news web sites and on TV and radio. Listening to Rush Limbaugh this afternoon, he launched into a tirade that this died-in-the-wool Conservative felt was entirely out-of-line.

Rush, commenting on an ABCnews.com article whose headline read, "Poorest Hit Hardest By Hurricane Katrina" lamblasted the liberal media for missing the big picture. He claimed, correctly, that the hurricane did not distinguish between the rich and the poor. He went on though to say that the poor were no harder hit or hindered than the middle or upper class. He continued on in this vein until I had to turn him off.

Here's the deal people - the poor were hurt and will continue to be hurt much longer than the middle or upper class. Let's think about this:

  • The poor, esp in New Orleans, don't have cars and couldn't flee the area, the middle class probably aren't holed up at the Superdome
  • The middle class had the means to not only jump in their cars to flee the region, but to afford a hotel a few hours away for a couple of nights (which now will be much longer)
  • According to media reports, only 1 in 5 have flood insurance. Am I to guess that those 20% are the poor, or the more well off?
  • The poor are more likely to be renters. Renters have lower net worth and probably no ability to move and build something. Me thinks there will be a severe lack of rental property throughout the region for quite some time.
  • The poor, usually with little or no job skills, will have a much more difficult time finding employment than someone with an insured house, ability to move to another city and a college education making them valuable to employers.

I could go on, but I think you are capable of doing the same. On the other hand, save those with "no means" to escape, the Biloxi mayor stated, "this is our tsunami." That too is incorrect. The tsunami hit without any warning whatsoever. Although perhaps devastating, the people of that city and the region had plenty of warning that something was coming their way and perhaps they should vacate. In general, the poorest American is much better off than those effected by the tsunami. A very bad analogy. An earthquake that destroys a wide region would be a better analogy.

7 comments

Comment from: Cathi [Visitor] · http://lazycat.typepad.com
Great post. I linked to this article from Jim Wallis about this very topic, and you've said the same thing much better than I ever could. The hurricane hit the rich and poor at the same time, but with unequal impact.
08/31/05 @ 17:47
Comment from: DOUG HARRY [Visitor]
Thank you for the analysis. It is thoughtful and pithy.

We all need to become Americans again. This liberal/conservative rhetoric is destructive in a time of common disaster.

The division becomes a license to the worst among us to take up arms.

Unity is the great need today.
09/01/05 @ 09:13
Comment from: pittcaleb [Member] Email
A new article today at Yahoo! News:
"Anger rises among Mississippi's poor after Katrina"
09/01/05 @ 11:16
Comment from: john [Visitor]
Rush Limbaugh is a disgusting person. He has no sympathy for regular people, because he is unable to confront and accept his own failings and weaknesses. That's why he ended up a junkie, and never admitted it. He thinks he's absovled, because he's rich.

The poorest African Americans of New Orleans didn't choose to live there. Their ancestors were sold to people "down the river." The ones who are left there are the people who couldn't get it together to move northward.
09/02/05 @ 16:52
Comment from: Frank Mallalieu [Visitor]
Does anyone know the address of Jonah Goldberg's Blog, in particular where he described Katrina vanden Heuvel (editor of The Nation)as Hurricane Katrina vanden Heuvel?
10/30/05 @ 18:34
Comment from: instant cash advance [Visitor] · http://www.sonicloans.net/
I don’t usually reply to posts but I will in this case. WoW :)
04/20/10 @ 15:11
Comment from: annunci gratuiti [Visitor] · http://www.bachecaweb.eu
bachecaweb.eu è un sito di annunci gratuiti online, con diverse sezioni: abbigliamento, animali, antiquariato e collezionismo, arredamento, attività commerciali , audio – video, benessere fitness e sport, corsi e lezioni, elettr. - casa – cucina, immobili vendita – affitto, informatica e accessori
08/13/10 @ 04:59

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.

Your URL will be displayed.
PoorExcellent
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Name, email & website)
(Allow users to contact you through a message form (your email will not be revealed.)